IN THIS ISSUE

Volume XXXVII
Nos. 1 and 2 Fall 2001

J.J. Sullivan Hotel & Tweeds Restaurant Restoration
Panorama
Help Us Collect 20th Century
Landmark Controls
TWA Terminal at JFK
Historic Preservation Issues
  Books Received
  Saved, Endangered, Lost
  Brooklyn
  Queens
  Nassau
  Suffolk
  Goodyear House
Homes for sale
Preservation Notes Home
   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

 

 

 

 

ENDANGERED

Beach Hampton/ Napeague
A World War II block house/watchtower is located on the dunes east of Amagansett at Whaler’s Lane. The concrete bunker was carefully camouflaged as a fisherman’s cottage. The block house was used as a “look-out” during World War II in connection with Coast Guard maneuvers. An intrinsic part of the history of Long Island and part of our cultural and military history, presently, the owner has applied for a demolition permit.



Hopping House.
PHOTOCREDIT: SOCIETY FOR THE PRESERVATION OF LONG ISLAND ANTIQUITIES

Bridgehampton
Community efforts are underway to protect the 160-year-old Hopping House at the corner of Montauk Highway and Ocean Road in Bridgehampton, designed and built by portrait painter, Nathaniel Rogers. This once-elegant Greek Revival-style house, noted for its handsome two-story columns across the front, is called one of the finest remaining examples of this type on the South Fork. A Connecticut development firm is seeking to buy the 5.6-acre property and build a shopping plaza. Though still in the planning stages the building project is being met with opposition. In July, 2000, more than 500 Bridgehampton residents signed petitions to preserve the Hopping property as residential space citing traffic and other environmental impacts. In December the Bridgehampton Citizens Advisory Committee formally opposed the project. In mid-December, the Southampton Town Landmarks and Historic Districts Board met to discuss designating the Hopping House as an historic landmark. This past July, theTown of Southampton changed its landmark ordinance to require owner consent before designation. A group of about 25 Bridgehampton residents have created the Bridgehampton Preservation Alliance to make sure their opposition to the development is being heard. More recently the developers have scaled down the project, including preservation of the Hopping House on-site, as part of their plans.



Arnold Constable.
PHOTOCREDIT:
ROBERT SARGENT

Hempstead Village

Two buildings in Hempstead Village, the retail center of Nassau County between 1920 and 1950, are threatened by a newly proposed urban renewal plan to develop an area bounded by North Franklin, High and Front Streets. Within this area is the former Arnold Constable store, built in 1940, the first New York City Department store to open on Long Island. Proposed for demolition, it presently houses a mix of commercial uses. The two story building is clad in limestone and curves around the block in the American modern streamlined style. The two main entrances retain their original ornate grillwork. There is also community concern for the Hempstead Post Office, although specifically protected from demolition in the new plan. It is a simple yellow brick building decorated with elaborately carved limestone panels at the cornice line and Art Moderne light torches at the front door. Built in 1932, the architectswere Tooker and Marsh, with James A. Wetmore serving as supervising architect. Wetmore also designed the North addition to the Brooklyn Post office in 1933 and the U.S. Post Office in Flushing in 1932. Soaring walls at either end of the interior are decorated with colorful WPA murals painted in 1937 by the artist Mangravite. A striking effect is created by the contrast of green marble panels and aluminum trim on the walls. Also surviving are the original spun aluminum tables with urn-shaped pedestals.


 


Twyford in 2001.
PHOTOCREDIT: SEATUCK
ENVIRONMENTAL ASSOC.

Islip
The Seatuck Environmental Association’s (SEA) efforts to renovate Twyford, the former home of Charles and Natalie Peters Webster, to operate an environmental education center atthe Seatuck National Wildlife Refuge has again been denied by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. The intention of the Fish and Wildlife Service is to return the land on which the dwelling sits to its natural state, a goal, the FWS feels, is best accomplished by allowing the property to deteriorate to the point of demolition. SEA believes that the opening of an environmental education center will have minimal impact on the refuge and will serve an important mission to educate Long Islanders regarding Long Island’s native plants and animals. Emphasizing that the house and outbuildings are eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places, New York State Office of Parks Recreation and Historic Preservation’s Commissioner, Bernadette Castro, has recently written the U.S Fish and Wildlife Service, offering the assistance of the State Historic Preservation Office and asking that the Fish and Wildlife Service reconsider their position and allow the SEA to pursue adaptive reuse of the house. A National Register nomination is currently being prepared by the State Historic Preservation Office.



Setauket Rubber Factory
Workers Housing

East Setauket
The Setauket Rubber Factory Workers dwellings from the late 1800’s on Old Town Road are significant as one of the few remaining examples of 19th century employee housing. They also represent a small pocket of affordable housing. The property is located to the rear of the Setauket Fire Department headquarters on Route 25A, which has purchased it toexpand fire department facilities. Presently these houses are vacant and are not being maintained. The fire department has offered them to anyone who will move them.



Parrish Art Museum
on Jobs Lane.
PHOTO CREDIT: SOCIETY FOR THE PRESERVATION OF LONG ISLAND ANTIQUITIES

Southhampton
Expansion plans for the Parrish Art Museum on Jobs Lane, have generated considerable controversy. Officials of the New York State Historic Preservation Office, the Village’s own Architectural Review Board and alocally organized preservation advocacy group, the Southampton Preservation Society, have criticized the plans, not yet formally filed with the Village. At issue are 35,000 square feet of proposed additions which, if implemented as proposed, will destroy important architectural, contextual, and landscape elements of the National Register-listed site. The museum site contains a Grosvenor Atterbury designed museum building, which was constructed in 1913, a formal landscaped garden designed by Warren H. Manning, with a lily pond, also designed by Atterbury, within the garden. According to the chair of the ARB, Samuel Parrish intended that the garden serve as a screened public park in the middle of the business district.


Rogers Memorial Library Building.
PHOTOCREDIT: SOCIETY FOR THE PRESERVATION OF LONG ISLAND ANTIQUITIES

There is also concern for the impact to the streetscape of the Southampton Village Historic District in which the property is situated and to the adjacent Robert H. Robertson designed Rogers Memorial Library Building which is planned to be used for art education. The museum purchased the building in 1999 and has renamed it the Carroll Petrie Center for Education. The Village has accepted a $15,000 grant from the Preservation League of New York State to hire Patricia M. O’Donnell, a landscape architect with offices in Norwalk, Connecticut and Charlotte, Vermont to produce an historic landscape report, to assist the village in evaluating potential impacts to the formal garden and arrive at a plan acceptable to all parties.