IN THIS ISSUE

Volume XXXVII
Nos. 1 and 2 Fall 2001

J.J. Sullivan Hotel & Tweeds Restaurant Restoration
Panorama
Help Us Collect 20th Century
Landmark Controls
TWA Terminal at JFK
Historic Preservation Issues
  Books Received
  Saved, Endangered, Lost
  Brooklyn
  Queens
  Nassau
  Suffolk
  Goodyear House
Homes for sale
Preservation Notes Home
   

 

 




SUFFOLK


Old Babylon Town Hall.
PHOTOCREDIT: BABYLON BY THE SEA,
IMAGES OF AMERICA SERIES, SR. ANNE FRANCIS PULLING,
ARCADIA PUBLISHING, CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA, 2000

Babylon
Local residents in Babylon have mounted a campaign to save the Old Babylon Town Hall. Built in 1917, the former town hall building, at 47 Main Street, was designed by architect Lewis Inglee. This building, which is eligible for the National and State Registers of Historic Places, was featured in 1936 in Vernon Howe Bailey’s NY Sun column, “Sketches of New York’s Suburbs,” item #235.


15 East Main Street (Deer Park Avenue) Store.
PHOTOCREDIT: LONG ISLAND LANDMARKS, METROPOLITAN NEW YORK
DISTRICT OFFICEOFTHE STATE OFFICE OF PLANNING COORDINATION,
EDWARD J. SMITS CONSULTANT, SPLIA, 1971

Another building of unusual significance in the Village of Babylon, is the 2 1/2story mansard roof commercial building at 15 East Main Street on the northeast corner of Main Street and Deer Park Avenue. The storefronts on the first floor have been modernized, but the upper floors retain a high degree of integrity and represent one of the very few surviving examples of a building type that was once not uncommon in Long Island’s turn-of-the-century business districts. The structure with commercial space on the ground floor and housing above, was illustrated and selected as “of particular interest” in Long Island Landmarks first published in 1969 by the Metropolitan New York District Office of the State Office of Planning Coordination where it was rated as of “County and Town significance” as a major structure and an outstanding example of special interest.

Both structures—the old Town Hall and the mansard roof commercial building at 15 East Main Street—are shown on page 86 of Suffolk County’s Ten Great Townships of Long Island, published in 1939 by Suffolk County Board of Supervisors.


Second Avenue Firehouse, Bay Shore, after restoration.
PHOTOCREDIT: GENE LESSERON

Bay Shore Second Avenue Firehouse The South Shore Restoration Group Inc. has meticulously restored Bay

Shore’s Second Avenue ca. 1897 firehouse, with support from local banks, private donors, the Suffolk County Legislature and a member grant from State Senator Owen Johnson. Known historically as the Bay Shore Hose Company No.1 building, the building had lost its hose-drying tower and its belfry, but old photographs from the Bay Shore Historical Society and Bay Shore Fire Department made replacement possible. The restoration architect, Anthony Szekalski, who directed the project, won for his firm the year 2000 historic restoration/reuse award from the New York chapter of the American Institute of Architects. The firehouse was rededicated on June 11, 2000.


North Elevation showing detail of restored hose-drying tower.
ELEVATION CREDIT: ANTHONY SZEKALSKI, AIA, BAY SHORE

Recognizing the building’s Stick Style architecture, cultural interest, and remarkable survival, the Department of the Interior listed it on the National Register of Historic Places on August 15, 2001. The building is a rehabilitation success story. Although it had outlived its original function, it lives again as a studio and home for husband and wife artists-in-residence, who, in exchange for a lower rent donate their talents to various community projects. This project makes an inspiring contribution to the ongoing efforts to up-grade Bay Shore’s historic business district—where a 1905 Queen Anne Style commercial building, owned by Marilyn Schulman of Bay Shore Lighting, received an elaborate facade restoration by architects Smiros and Smiros using original photographs.

Adding to the historic preservation ferment, the United Methodist Church of Bay Shore, located on the northwest corner of Second Avenue and East Main Street, was listed on the State and National Registers in 2001. It is a large handsome Romanesque Revival Style building with an auditorium in the so-called “Akron Plan.” Although the architect has not been identified, it is said to be similar to work by George F. Skidmore, a prominent Riverhead architect. The First Congregational Church of Bay Shore, built in 1891 has also been listed on the State Register and nominated to the National Register of Historic Places in 2001. Krueger, Anne ”Second Acts” This Old House, December, 2000


World War Veterans Club.
PHOTOCREDIT: EVELYN ELLIS,
VILLAGE HISTORIAN

Lindenhurst World War Veterans Club
First formed in 1919, the World War Veterans Club, after meeting initially in fire district headquarters on West John Street and later in other rented headquarters, determined to construct a clubhouse of their own. The members purchased two lots in 1924 on the corner of West John Street and North Broadway for $500 dollars. Architectural plans were drawn by Harry Wichman. In October, 1926 a contract was signed with George Weierter for $5,160 to construct the building. The outside walls of the clubhouse were of magnesite stucco, with a watch tower and crenellated parapet.

Due to declining membership, the club can no longer support the building. Members’ strong concern that the structure be preserved has led them to initiate a purchase for $50,000 by Suffolk County, which is intending to turn it over to the Town of Babylon for use as a veterans museum. Suffolk County Legislator David Bishop of the 14th Legislative District, which includes Lindenhurst, and Councilman Steve Bellone of the Town of Babylon, have facilitated the purchase and prospective transfer. The signing of the contract is pending a resolution by Suffolk County, stipulating its future use be restricted to use by the World War Veterans Club of Lindenhurst, Inc. as long as it may continue to exist. A resolution has been passed by the Town of Babylon Town Board authorizing the acceptance of the building. Office of David Bishop, Suffolk County Legislator, 14th Legislative District—Evelyn M. Ellis, Lindenhurst Village Historian


Chandlery, Bayles Shipyard, Port Jefferson.
PHOTOCREDIT: THE SEVEN HILLS OF PORT,
PATRICIA HANSELL SISLERAND
ROBERT SISLER,
RMP PUBLICATION SERVICES

Port Jefferson
The Bayles Shipyard at 101 East Broadway in Port Jefferson has been nominated to the National Register of Historic Places. This is a five-acre waterfront property which has three buildings port. These are the 1897 Bayles Chandlery (from 1953 to 1986 the office of Tuthill & Young Oil Co.), the 1917 Machine Shop and Mould Loft, and the 1917 Compressor House. By 1917 the wooden shipbuilding era was over and new owners leased the shipyard to the Emergency Fleet Corporation of the United States Shipping Board. All the old structures except the Bayles handlery were demolished and the yard was adapted to the construction of large steel vessels. From remaining from the days when Port Jefferson was Long Island’s major shipbuilding 1917 to 1921 the Bayles Shipyard Inc. had a workforce of about 1000 men and constructed nine steel-hulled freighters, barges, tugboats, and tankers. The last vessel was launched in 1921. In order to house the supervisory personnel the Emergency Fleet Corporation built a row of small houses on nearby Liberty Avenue with Sir Alfred C. Bossom as architect. Alfred C. Bossom, who was London-born and trained, came to America in 1904 as an associate of architect George A. Crawley on the John L. Phipps estate in Old Westbury. He designed two country homes on Long Island, in 1914 and in 1918, but his main thrust was a variety of major commercial and industrial commissions including two company towns and, toward the close of World War I, “the housing development for Bayles Shipyard Inc. in Port Jefferson undertaken by the Emergency Fleet Corporation for the U.S. Shipping Board.” This information is from Long Island Country Houses and Their Architects 1860- 1940 published by SPLIA in 1997.