IN THIS ISSUE

Volume XXXVIII
Nos. 1 and 2 Fall 2002

Modernism Survey

350th Anniversary, Huntington and Oyster Bay
New Initiatives to Preserve Historic Environments
Montauk Playhouse
Long Island and the Underground Railroad
Old Nassau County Courthouse
Long Island
National Register Listings
Historic Preservation Issues
  Suffolk
  Nassau
  Saved,
Endangered, Lost
Homes for sale

Books
Received

Preservation Notes Home
   

 

 

 
Montauk Playhouse


The Montauk Playhouse, known originally as the Montauk Tennis Auditorium, was built between 1928 and 1929. Together with the Montauk Manor and the Fisher Building, it was part of developer Carl Fisher’s vision of a Miami of the north. With the stock market crash, his vision was eclipsed, but the striking buildings he left behind have demanded the attention of residents and visitors ever since. The estimated cost of constructing the Tennis Auditorium was $125,000, a large sum for the late 1920s. Envisioned as a multi-purpose building it was planned not only for tennis but for boxing matches and large-scale conferences.

After the stock market crash the Tennis Auditorium continued to operate, serving primarily as the indoor tennis courts for the Montauk Manor. During World War II, the Tennis Auditorium was transformed into an assembly hall and theater for the troops. In the 1950s, it served as a summer stock theater and was renamed the Montauk Manor Playhouse. It did not succeed and found a new use as a movie theater. Abandoned in the 1970s and only used minimally thereafter, the building deteriorated to the point of precariousness, but its architectural features and historical interest were recognized with its listing on the National Register of Historic Places in 1987. The last few years have seen important progress toward restoration and reuse of the structure. In 1999, the owners donated the Playhouse and its 4.4 acres of surrounding property to the Town of East Hampton. The Montauk Playhouse Community Center Foundation , a friends group was formed. In Fall, 2001, a Town of East Hampton advisory committee recommended that the building be restored and used as a community center. Recently the Town of East Hampton received a $350,000 Environmental Protection Fund grant for restoration. The Preservation League of the State of New York listed the property on its 2002 Seven-to Save list, recognizing both the significance of the structure, and the pivotal role it can still play in the life of its community.